July 24th, 2008Hungry for Power: Split Those Atoms!
Over a year has passed since 新潟県 (Niigata Prefecture) suffered a massive offshore earthquake. Measuring 7 on Japan’s scale of 7, the Kashiwazaki-Kariwa nuclear power plant quickly shut down the four reactors operating at the time. Aside from an outdoor transformer catching fire and some radioactive material from a spent fuel storage pool leaking into the sea, there was no major damage to the plant. The International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) has inspected the plant twice and found no serious damage to the facilities. So this begs the question: Why isn’t the plant brought back online?
Disaster prevention was key in the design of this nuclear power plant, and the safety mechanisms worked near-perfectly. The reactors were quickly shut down through automated systems, the rods were secured, and not one life was lost. The facility was hit with a quake measuring 7 out of 7, in a country where Richter’s Scale just won’t do, and it’s still standing. Surely this is a redeeming qualification to resume power generation in a country where a summer-time electrical consumption rate of 98.2% capacity is considered “expected.”
Oddly enough … no.
The seven nuclear power reactors, which together are capable of generating 8.21 GigaWatts (more than any other plant on Earth), will remain offline for the summer and probably until sometime in mid-to-late-2009.
About As Green As An American SUV
Electricity is insanely important in Japan as anything that can be plugged into a wall socket is plugged into a wall socket. Chairs, sofas, coffee tables, aquariums, book shelves, digital scales, toothbrushes, and throw rugs. Anything and everything that can have a computer chip, light bulb or fan, usually gets one … whether it’s necessary or not. With such a reliance on power, the Japanese public will not tolerate such Third-World situations as rolling blackouts or, heaven forbid, brown-outs. To this end, the Tokyo Electric Power Company (TEPCO) resumed operations at two thermal power plants in 横須賀市 (Yokosuka). While this will help compensate for the lost power generation from Kashiwazaki-Kariwa, it will also emit an extra 30,000,000 tonnes of CO² into the atmosphere.
Yay.
Despite the rage and insults lobbed at China for their excessive use of coal-powered plants, few people pay attention to where their electrical power comes from. With so much of the country flirting dangerously with shortages this summer, it’s time for us to think about these issues. TEPCO must show that it’s implemented a dynamic set of safety measures if it wants to resume operations at Kashiwazaki-Kariwa, and government agencies need to make more of an effort to educate the public on the need for nuclear power plants.
Whether this will happen, though, remains to be clear.













































Oh, some radioactive material leaked into the sea? Ah, that’s no big deal, who cares!
With that much power being produced in one location, I can certainly see how it would be important to get it back online and I wonder why the people in charge are dragging their feet at letting that happen? Also, it must be costing the company that owns it an insane amount of money to have it sitting there not producing.
The radioactive material that leaked into the sea is definately not one of those things that can be passed off as a “who cares” so easily, however, when you consider that this was the only external problem after a maximum yield earthquake occurred, you can’t complain with the outcome. Had the plant been designed like the one in Chernobyl, there’d be a 250-km no-life zone surrounding the operation.
As for cost, everybody is suffering. The owners of the plant are losing millions of yen every day, and the region is also losing lots of money at the same time. The nuclear plant was responsible for employing over 13,000 people (both directly and indirectly). Also, by having a nuclear plant in the city, both the prefecture and the community was able to receive money from the government. Now that the plant is not producing electricity, not only are there 13,000 people unemployed, but the region isn’t receiving the money it needs for other programs.
By keeping a working power plant that has passed the safety checks of both the Japanese energy production organization and the IAEA, the people of the region are losing and the people of Japan are now using power from higher polluting power sources to compensate for the loss.
This is one of those lose-lose-lose situations, and it doesn’t look like it’ll be over anytime soon
I also agree. I have long felt that nuke power in modern plants is very safe. The power is extremely clean when compared to coal power plants. Without even thinking of global warming, the disease and death caused by air pollution from coal fired power plants worldwide is immense. They ALL need to be shut down. We can only do that with a mix of nuke power plants and clean energy such as wind, solar, etc.
Japan has a poor track record when it comes to nuclear power plant operations, especially when it comes to proper maintenance. What’s worse are the cover-ups after accidents or incidents, including Kashiwazaki. They immediately tried to cover up how much was spilled and the true amounts were discovered within the week. It’s not even done cleverly; it’s like a child who has accidentally broken a flower pot scooping up handfuls of potting soil off the carpet and tossing them behind the sofa and then saying, when mom walks in the room, “Just a little dirt spilled, Mommy!” That’s why there’s so much distrust regarding nuclear power among ordinary citizens in this country.
I support the use of nuclear power to generate energy as long as everything’s run kosher at the plants.
I agree that many Japanese companies have a poor grasp regarding the importance of plausibility and completeness of their lies, however, Japan does not have many other alternatives when it comes to generating the amount of power that is, and will soon be, required by the consumers and businesses in the country.
Safety is certainly something we should worry about, but if an international body reports something is safe, that should be enough of a green light for a partial restart. If companies wish to lie about their accidents, perhaps the feds could assemble yet another powerless committee to draft some laws for the next Prime Minister to enact